I picked up these fun bags from Pick Your Plum a few weeks ago, and thought they'd be perfect.
I put 5-6 pieces of toffee in them. These would also be great to put a cookie or two in. Then I used used some fun washi tape and taped it shut. I added a tag by punching a whole in the top corner and I was finished. This was very quick to do, it isn't too girly (I ran that by my husband) and it looks cute!